
The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has with immediate effect withdrawn Lusaka lawyer Robert Simeza as a co-prosecutor in the murder case involving Inktech managing director Mohan Matthews and others.
In his letter to Mr Simeza dated July 20 this year, Mr Chalwe Mchenga indicated that his action to immediately withdraw him had been necessitated to protect the integrity of the trial process.
This is in a case in which Matthews and Crown Paints proprietors Idris Suleiman Patel and Shabbir Patel have been charged with the alleged murder of Cyclone Hardware managing director Sajid Itowala on July 21, 2009.
“ This letter serves to advise that I have with immediate effect withdrawn the authority for you to co-prosecute the case of ‘The People Vs Mohan Matthews and others, my action has been necessitated to protect the integrity of the trial process.
“ And the inconvenience that the very short notice may cause you and your clients is deeply regretted,” said the DPP.
And the respondent’s family representative and uncle of the deceased, Mr Mohamed Suleman Itowala had filed an appeal against the DPP’s decision to withdraw Mr Simeza as a co-prosecutor in the matter.
In his affidavit, Mr Itowala alleged that he had authority to depose his support of Mr Simeza as co –prosecutor and that as family, they were comfortable with the way he had been prosecuting the case and felt that justice was going on well.
Mr Itowala said as the family they had been grandly taken aback and distressed by the turn of events that the person who had primary conduct of the prosecution would no longer be able to direct the prosecution at this advanced stage of the case.
“ That I and the family are desirous to see Mr Simeza continue to play a role in this matter as he is well versed with the facts of the case as he has spent time interviewing witnesses including those who may not be called to testify, he will be of great service in easing the mind of the deceased’s family and of great value to the court,” he said.
Mr Itowala indicated that allowing Mr Simeza to continue a role in the prosecution of this case would go along way towards ensuring that justice was not only done but also manifestly seen to be done.
That this case was the first of its kind in Zambia and had generated enormous public interest especially in the Muslim community and as such there should not be any lingering doubt as to the manner the prosecution would have been conducted.
But Mr Mchenga in his response said his withdraw of Mr Simeza from the case was not as a result of any misconduct on his part but followed his assessment that it was not in the broad interest of justice for this case to continue to be prosecuted by a private legal practitioner.
“ This being the case I will not reverse my decision to withdraw Mr Simeza from the case, neither will I allow any other private legal practitioner to join in the prosecution,” Mr Mchenga said.
He said it was his obligation to act as he did knowing well that his decision might not be well received by interested parties like him and his family and apologised for his action and the inconvenience.
The matter has been set for August 9, for continued trial.
[ Times of Zambia ]